Final Essay Ethics - 5945 Words

Final Essay A Case Study of Roche’s Drug Trials in China Introduction In business we must evaluate decisions along ethical lines and we must recognize that, for the long-term benefit of society, we cannot always make these decisions based simply upon a profit motive. The following case exemplifies the complexities inherent in business decisions. The case examined addresses whether it is worth doing something ethically questionable for the sake of a justified end. In 2010, the pharmaceutical company Roche came under fire from Traidos Bank, the Berne Declaration, Greenpeace, and other critics for its policy of testing an organ transplantation drug called CellCept in China. CellCept is a drug designed to â€Å"prevent the rejection of†¦show more content†¦As Roche makes clear, â€Å"CellCept was a medicine which had saved and continued to save thousands of patients’ lives by preventing post-transplant organ rejection.† If CellCept can receive regulatory approval in China then it could improve the lives of many people, as well as save them from other costly or less effective alternatives. In order to properly conduct an ethical analysis of this case study, each relevant party must be distinctly identified. The primary decision maker, the pharmaceutical company Roche, holds an interest in the revenues it would receive from regulatory approval. While it is easy to assume that businesses are driven solely by the profit motiv e, the company spokesperson’s statement, â€Å"Withdrawing [CellCept] from the market in any country would be morally unthinkable†, indicates that Roche may be legitimately interested in the welfare of its end users. The party most impacted by Roche’s decision is medical patients waiting for organ transplants in China. This party is actually made up of two categories: those patients who will participate in Roche drug trials, and those who would receive the drug CellCept only in the event of Chinese regulatory approval. We can assume both of these groups belong to the same patient party for the following reasons. First, Roche has indicated that independent institutions conduct organ procurement, and we have been given no information to indicate that procurement procedures are different for test patients asShow MoreRelatedMedical Ethics Final Essay : Medicine1553 Words   |  7 Pages Medical Ethics Final Essay Salem Mojadidi CSU Eastbay Professor Smith HSC 3720 November 21, 2014 The day I woke up and realized that my cousins were randomly sleeping on my bedroom floor knew there was something wrong; I was right. In the summer of 2005 my aunt was diagnosed with breast cancer and the doctor said that there was a 50/50 chance that she would live since it was in an advanced stageRead MoreAnalysis Of Eric Katz s Nazi Engineers 931 Words   |  4 Pagessocieties ethics ultimately determine the direction in which society moves. Katz writes this essay with the purpose to educate his students about Nazi ethics so that they can avoid the moral reasoning used by the Nazi’s. In order to articulate the reasoning of the Nazi’s, Katz uses three main ethical ideologies used in the Nazi society; Technological Neutrality, Doubling, and Integration and Ideology in engineering. Technological neutrality embodies the more traditional view on technological ethics inRead MoreResolving Bioethical Issues Is No Easy Task1442 Words   |  6 Pagesâ€Å"appeals to general principles or rules to arrive at a more specific moral conclusion through some form of inference† (Tomlinson 1). While principles are important in ethical reasoning, they are just one method for analyzing bioethical issues. In this essay, I will explicate what is meant by the statement, â€Å"principles are necessary but not sufficient for work in bioethics† and in doing so, I will provide arguments in concurrence with the statemen t. In determining what is meant by the statement, â€Å"principlesRead MoreThe Scientific Method Essays1678 Words   |  7 Pagesman. In the final analysis Socrates conversation with Euthyphro, smashes all of Euthyphro’s ideas and conceptions. Euthypro’s belief system has diminished and what he thought may be sound, good reasoning concerning the gods proves to be meaningless conversation. Euthyphro speaks in fallacy, Socrates sees right through it; and that is apparent in his questioning toward the young man. W. K. Clifford wrote an essay titled â€Å"The Ethics of Belief† in which he â€Å"argues that there is an ethic to belief thatRead More Aldo Leopolds A Sand County Almanac Essay731 Words   |  3 Pageswith the U.S. Forest Service, across the southern border into Chihuahua and Sonora, Mexico, north to Oregon and Utah, and finally across the northern border into Manitoba, Canada. These dilemmas brought up in Part II make the Round River essays, inserted as the modern edition’s Part III, titled A Taste for Country, particularly apt, because this is the section of the book that deals primarily with philosophies. It is here that Leopold states that poor land may be rich country, and viceRead MoreQuestions On Ethics And Human Sciences1423 Words   |  6 Pagesknowledge. This essay will investigate mainly two of them: ethics and human sciences. Ethics try to answer the question â€Å"what is good and what is wrong† . In this case whether helping the poor is good or wrong. The next area of knowledge that I will be using is history. I will mainly focus on some of the historical events that determine the opinions of two different experts who present two opposite aspects of poverty. Now, I will focus on the first area of knowledge which are ethics. Assuming thatRead MoreHow Personal Responsibility Will Lead to My Success Essay1089 Words   |  5 Pagesresponsibility will lead to my success in and beyond school because it gives me the confidence to succeed, and will lead to a better life for my family and me. Now as to my approach for this paper I am writing this essay according to The Descriptive Essay (2011), The descriptive essay is a genre of essay that asks the student to describe an object, person, place, experience, emotion, situation, etc. This genre encourages the student’s ability to create a written account of a particular experience. What isRead MoreVisual Exploration Of Video Games1260 Words   |  6 Pagesresponsibility and teamwork. As a result I was able to become a competent individual worker as well as a responsible collaborator. The multimodal nature of the artifacts developed my existing skills and brought me out of my comfort zone of traditional essay writing. The review process was another major way that I was able to develop as a multimodal communicator. While I still have room to improve in the creativity and visual components of my work, this course has given me much needed exposure to theseRead MoreThe Walking Embodiment Of Stress In School1064 Words    |  5 Pagesthings, an easy A and plenty of time to chat with teachers. Teaching has always been a dream of Heber’s, though today’s conversations have been rather dull, Mr. Martin, Heber’s teacher this nine weeks has yet to even looked up from the mounds of redo essays, at least nothing more than a quick nod of welcome. The room is fairly well managed, seeing as how most Seniors are actually passing and no real work gets done the last few weeks so there is nothing for Heber to sort through or help organize. TheRead MoreBusiness 115 Final Exam Study Guide Essay1334 Words   |  6 PagesBUSN115 Final Exam Study Guide The BUSN115 final exam is 3 pages long. It is a timed exam worth 250 points that you may enter only once. You have 3.5 hours to complete the exam. It consists of 30 multiple choice questions worth 5 points each. There are 5 essay questions worth 20 points each. Be sure to save and save often while you are working on the exam, and submit the exam when you are finished. To earn full credit your response to each essay question should answer the question completely